A match was then set for Unforgiven with the stipulation that if Test won, he would not only retain Keibler's services, She was then placed in a feud involving Smack Down!divas Torrie Wilson and then-babyface, Sable, who both had recently posed for a Playboy cover.

In season seven, however, Keibler was seen as a victim of a prank by her then-boyfriend, Geoff Stults. Special Maxim's Celebrity Beach Watch: 15 Hottest Bodies on September 16, 2009, and The Ultimate Spike Girl 2009 Finale on Spike TV on October 1, 2009.

On January 11, 2010, Keibler appeared as "the hot bartender", a new conquest for Barney, in the How I Met Your Mother 100th episode, "Girls Versus Suits".

Keibler was a contestant on the second season of Dancing with the Stars, where she placed third.

She has also appeared on other American Broadcasting Company (ABC) shows such as What About Brian, George Lopez, and October Road, as well as the 100th episode of the CBS sitcom How I Met Your Mother as a bartender and on the USA Network show Psych.

During this feud the four Divas competed in the first-ever tag team Bra and Panties Match at the In Vasion pay-per-view, which Trish and Lita won by stripping Stacy down to her yellow underwear and Torrie Wilson to her white underwear.

During this time, she began an on-screen rivalry with former ally Torrie Wilson after Wilson left The Alliance, with Keibler helping The Dudley Boyz put Torrie through a table.As Test's on-screen marketing agent, she came up with the idea that Test should call his fans "Testicles," cut his hair, and reshape his image.The couple were originally villains but due to popularity of the gimmick, they became fan favorites.It was also during this period that she began using what would become her trademark ring entrance: slowly putting her forty-two inch legs through the second tier of ropes, pausing to let the crowd momentarily see her panties.For a brief period, she dated David Flair (both on-screen and off), who was already involved in an on-screen relationship with Daffney.Torrie, however, got her revenge after giving Keibler a wedgie then pantsing her on an episode of Smack Down! A key storyline for Keibler's on-screen character occurred when she left Smack Down! Keibler made her official Raw debut on August 12, 2002.